
Two Indiana men are under arrest and face federal fraud charges. Prosecutors say their Indianapolis investment firm ran one of the biggest alleged Ponzi schemes in the state’s history, taking in about $600 million from more than 2,000 investors.
Phillip Williams of Kokomo and Devin Johnson of Zionsville were arrested Wednesday, Nov. 18. According to court documents, the two ran Backward Hat Capital, an Indianapolis firm that promised investors huge monthly profits from foreign currency trading.
Prosecutors say most of those profits were never real.
The Promise: More Than 6% a Month
Backward Hat Capital told investors it used a special trading system to buy and sell foreign currencies, known as forex. According to the allegations, the fund reported returns of more than 6% per month, which works out to more than 100% a year.
Returns that high are far beyond what legitimate investments usually produce, and they’re a classic warning sign of fraud.
The Allegations: New Money Paid Old Investors
Court documents say that instead of trading investors’ money as promised, the company:
- Used more than $200 million from new investors to pay earlier investors who wanted their money back, the basic pattern of a Ponzi scheme
- Paid more than $130 million to Williams
- Paid more than $40 million to Johnson
“As alleged, Phillip Patrick Williams and Devin Allen Johnson promised to use investor funds for profitable foreign exchange currency trading,” U.S. Attorney Jamie McDonald said. Instead, McDonald said, they allegedly took hundreds of millions of dollars for personal expenses and to pay off earlier investors.
The Cracks Started Showing This Summer
According to investigators, Backward Hat began having trouble paying investors in summer 2026. Williams reportedly blamed banking and cryptocurrency problems. Investigators say most of the money was already gone by then.
The company also kept looking for new money. In October, an undercover IRS agent posed as a possible investor and received instructions on how to open an account.
A Second Fund and a Questionable Auditor
Investigators say the two men also launched a second fund, AI Capital LP. Johnson allegedly told a possible investor that the new fund had already lined up $75 million. Investigators say it hadn’t received any investor money at all.
Prosecutors also allege that the company’s supposedly independent auditor had undisclosed personal interests in Backward Hat, meaning the audits investors relied on may not have been independent.
Arrests in Kokomo and Arizona
Williams was arrested in Kokomo. Johnson was arrested in Arizona; reports say it was in Gilbert. According to reports, Williams is 51 and Johnson is 29.
Both face federal securities fraud and wire fraud charges. Combined, the charges carry up to 45 years in prison if they’re convicted.
Both men are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
Were You an Investor? The FBI Wants to Hear From You
The FBI’s Indianapolis Field Office is trying to find people who invested with Backward Hat Capital. If you invested with the company or anyone connected to it, or have information about the case, you can fill out the FBI’s online questionnaire at forms.fbi.gov.
Warning Signs of an Investment Scam
Experts say these red flags should make any investor stop and ask questions:
- Guaranteed high returns with little or no risk
- Unusually steady profits, even when markets are rough
- Complicated or secret strategies that no one can explain clearly
- Trouble withdrawing money, or excuses about “banking problems”
- Pressure to recruit friends and family
Before investing, you can look up a firm or adviser for free on FINRA’s BrokerCheck or the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure website.

Robert J. Anaya is a writer and editor at WAMB Radio, covering local news and crime news for Wabash-area communities and Rockville. He is committed to reporting accurate, fact-checked, and timely stories that help local readers stay informed and safe.


