
A North Carolina boy who loved model planes, history and Dungeons & Dragons was just three days away from turning 15. According to court records, he died after finding a loaded gun on the kitchen table while he and his younger brother were home alone overnight.
Now both of his parents are facing criminal charges.
Both Parents Charged
William David Howard Jr., 52, and Jennifer McGrath Butler, 49, are each charged with negligent child abuse resulting in serious bodily injury in the death of their son, William “Oscar” Howard, 14.
According to arrest warrants:
- Howard “provided the child and his 13-year-old brother with multiple firearms”
- Butler left the boys alone in the home with the guns
- Their actions were a “willful act and grossly negligent omission”
- Both parents showed a “reckless disregard for human life”
Left Alone Overnight
The warrants don’t give many details. However, a custody filing Howard later made against Butler offers more information about what happened.
According to that filing, the boys were staying with Butler at her home in Angier on Aug. 18, as part of the parents’ shared custody arrangement. Howard claimed Butler left the boys alone overnight and went to a beach about two hours away with her boyfriend.
“Upon information and belief, in the last few months Defendant has regularly left the minor children alone overnight to spend time with her boyfriend,” the filing says.
A Loaded Gun on the Kitchen Table
Around 8 p.m. that night, according to the filing, Oscar found a loaded gun on the kitchen table. An “accidental shooting occurred,” and he died. His younger brother was in his bedroom at the time.
Officers who arrived at the home pronounced Oscar dead.
The filing describes the house as being in “deplorable” condition, with empty liquor bottles and spoiled food in several rooms. Police recovered seven firearms from the home.
Howard asked the court for custody of the surviving son, saying Butler was “not fit to care” for him. He later dropped the request without explanation.
“He Could Lose Himself in the Details”
Oscar’s obituary remembers a curious, creative boy.
“Oscar had a remarkable number of interests and talents. He loved planes and flying games, Dungeons & Dragons, video games, history, and intricate model kits,” it reads. “He could lose himself in the details of almost anything that captured his imagination.”
He would have turned 15 three days after he died.
Court Dates Set
Both parents have posted bond and been released from jail.
- Howard is due back in court on Dec. 15
- Butler is due in court on Jan. 19
Both are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
North Carolina’s Gun Storage Law
North Carolina law requires gun owners to store firearms so that children can’t easily get to them. Leaving a loaded gun where a minor can reach it can lead to criminal charges, especially if a child is hurt.
Keeping Kids Safe Around Guns
Safety experts recommend:
- Storing guns unloaded and locked in a safe, lockbox or with a cable lock
- Keeping ammunition locked up separately
- Never leaving a gun unattended on a table, counter or nightstand
- Talking with kids about what to do if they find a gun: don’t touch it, leave the area, and tell an adult
Many local police departments and safety programs give out free gun locks.

Robert J. Anaya is a writer and editor at WAMB Radio, covering local news and crime news for Wabash-area communities and Rockville. He is committed to reporting accurate, fact-checked, and timely stories that help local readers stay informed and safe.


