Bodycam Shows Woman Calmly Making Coffee at Dealership Where She Allegedly Helped Steal $100K in Vehicles With a Stolen Identity, Then Deputies Slap on the Cuffs as Accomplice Bolts and Injures a Deputy

Bodycam Shows Woman Calmly Making Coffee at Dealership Where She Allegedly Helped Steal $100K in Vehicles With a Stolen Identity, Then Deputies Slap on the Cuffs as Accomplice Bolts and Injures a Deputy
Photo: Cam Stories TV

Most people accused of fraud stay far away from the place they allegedly scammed. Deputies say one woman in upstate New York did the opposite. Newly circulated bodycam footage shows her walking back into the same car dealership and making herself a cup of coffee, while sheriff’s deputies were inside investigating the fake paperwork she had allegedly signed.

The case, from Farmington, New York, ended with three arrests, a foot chase that left a deputy hurt, and both vehicles recovered.

A Cadillac, a Ford Truck and a Name That Wasn’t Theirs

On Aug. 11, 2025, Ontario County sheriff’s deputies were called to a car dealership on Route 96 in Farmington around 2:40 p.m. for a possible forgery and grand larceny.

Investigators say three people used another person’s identity to drive off with a Cadillac and a Ford truck. The sheriff’s office put their combined value at more than $100,000.

The paperwork looked real enough to get through the sale. It included a driver’s license, a Social Security card, and financing applications sent to two lenders, ESL and Empower. According to the bodycam footage, ESL even did a phone identity check before approving one of the deals.

“There’s No House”

The scheme started falling apart when the real woman whose identity had been used began getting alerts about vehicles she never bought. The lender then warned the dealership.

When employees looked more closely at the paperwork, they found that the home address on the documents was an empty lot.

“There’s no house,” an employee told a responding deputy.

By then, both vehicles had already been driven off the lot, and the dealership hadn’t received the financing money.

She Came Back for Coffee

That’s when the case took a strange turn. The dealership had told the buyers that one document, possibly a mileage statement, still needed a signature. While deputies were inside looking at the paperwork, a woman tied to the purchases came back and started making coffee.

A deputy walked up and asked why she was there. When he mentioned the Cadillac and the truck, she said she knew about them, but she seemed surprised when he told her fake identification had been used.

He told her to stop making coffee and come with him. Moments later, she was in handcuffs.

“I’ve never been arrested before,” she told the deputy.

Her Story: A “Luxury Rideshare Business”

During questioning, the woman said a former coworker had pitched her a plan to start a high-end transportation business using expensive vehicles. She said she wanted in but didn’t have the credit to qualify.

She said the coworker told her not to worry, because he would provide an ID. She admitted it had her photo but someone else’s name.

“I said, ‘Are you sure?’ Because I’m not trying to get into no criminal mastermind enterprise,” she recalled telling him.

She told deputies she never got money or either vehicle. Her role, she said, was to drive a Chrysler 300 she already owned. She also said she was struggling with money and housing, which made the offer appealing.

“I just wanted to be a part of the business,” she said.

When a deputy asked if it seemed suspicious that someone had made an ID with her face and another person’s information, she answered, “A little.”

A Wad of Cash, Then a Sprint for the Fence

While she was being questioned, other deputies were talking to the men involved. One man was carrying about $4,000 in cash, which he said was for bills and a car payment.

Then another man suddenly ran. Deputies chased him as he jumped a fence toward a nearby trailer park. One deputy hurt his knee during the chase. He was treated at F.F. Thompson Hospital and later returned to work.

The sheriff’s office used K9 teams and searched on foot, but the man got away that day.

Three Arrested, Both Vehicles Recovered

Deputies arrested Patrick Chase Johnson Jr., 34, of Rochester, and Iselynn Johnson, 36, of Pittsford, the same day. Both were charged with second-degree grand larceny, arraigned in CAP Court and released on their own recognizance, with more charges pending.

The man who ran was identified as Chaz Keon Davis, 42, of Rochester. Nine days later, on Aug. 20, deputies found him at a home on Forgham Circle in Rochester. He was charged with:

  • second-degree grand larceny
  • second-degree assault, for the deputy’s injury

Davis was held at the Ontario County Jail after his arraignment.

Both the Cadillac and the Ford truck were recovered.

Public records don’t say how the cases were finally resolved. All three suspects are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

A Warning for Dealers and Consumers

The case shows how stolen-identity fraud can get past several safety checks, including ID review, two lenders and a phone verification call. In this case, it took the real victim noticing alerts about loans she never took out to expose it.

Tip: Check your credit report regularly and turn on account alerts. If you see a loan or purchase you don’t recognize, contact the lender and report it right away.

Source

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top