
A 79-year-old Rochester, Indiana, woman was led away in handcuffs this month over a $37 check from nearly 20 years ago. Then two strangers stepped in, and her life took a very different turn.
Thanks to a Crawfordsville couple who had never met her, Judith “Judy” Michael is free, the charges against her have been dropped, and people across the area are now helping her get back on her feet.
Arrested at a Traffic Stop Over a 2006 Case
On Nov. 3, police pulled Michael over during a traffic stop in Warsaw. When officers checked her name, they found an old warrant from Montgomery County, about two hours away, for check fraud.
The case dated back to 2006. Michael had been accused of writing a $37 check to put gas in her car.
Michael, who lives in Rochester, spent the night in jail in Kosciusko County. She was then taken to Crawfordsville in Montgomery County.
“She was terrified,” said Heather Gemino. “She’d never been in handcuffs before, never been arrested. Definitely never been in a jail.”
“She Was Praying for an Angel”
Heather and Jamie Gemino of Crawfordsville didn’t know Michael. But when they heard about her situation, they say they felt they had to help.
The couple paid her $500 cash bond and also put down a $1,000 retainer to hire an attorney to fight the charges.
Heather Gemino said that when Michael was brought out, she looked confused and didn’t know who they were. Gemino told her they had never met, but something told her to come help.
“And that’s what she told us, that she was actually praying for an angel when they knocked on our door,” Gemino said.
Case Dismissed Before Her Court Date
The help worked. Michael’s case was dismissed on Nov. 13, three days before she was due in court on Nov. 16.
The Montgomery County prosecutor’s office declined an interview request from WSBT 22.
Alone After Losing Her Sister
The Geminos say they soon learned how difficult things had become for Michael.
“She really had no one. After she lost her sister, it’s just been her,” Heather Gemino said. “It was extremely sad to hear the situation that she was in and that she didn’t have anybody to call.”
Michael’s money problems began after she mortgaged her home to pay for her sister’s cancer treatment and funeral. Since then, she has struggled to keep up with bills, and some of her utilities have been shut off.
Community Raises Nearly $9,000
The Geminos started a GoFundMe to help Michael catch up on her bills. So far, the community has given nearly $9,000.
Jamie Gemino said what his wife did was about more than bailing someone out of jail.
“This is something God sent her to help her with, because I couldn’t imagine being a person in this world with nobody and to have those worries, and then to go a winter without heat,” he said.
How to Help
People who want to support Michael can search for the GoFundMe set up by the Gemino family. Before giving, always make sure a fundraiser is the official one shared by the organizers.

Robert J. Anaya is a writer and editor at WAMB Radio, covering local news and crime news for Wabash-area communities and Rockville. He is committed to reporting accurate, fact-checked, and timely stories that help local readers stay informed and safe.


