
A Casper woman told 911 she was the victim. Her own home security camera told a different story.
A Natrona County jury needed less than two hours on Wednesday to find Tabatha Richardson, 38, guilty of aggravated assault and battery. Prosecutors said she stabbed her husband in the neck while he sat on the couch feeding their infant son, after first bruising herself with a sledgehammer to make it look like he had abused her.
Two 911 Calls, Two Very Different Stories
Natrona County Sheriff’s deputies were called to the couple’s home in the 3300 block of Allendale in Casper on Dec. 9, 2025. Both Richardson and her husband had called 911.
The husband told dispatchers he was on the couch feeding the baby when Richardson said something to him “out of nowhere.” Then he felt something hit the right side of his neck. When he saw blood on his hand, he ran out of the house and called for help. He said the attack was unprovoked and that he was afraid for his children.
Richardson told a very different story. She said she “just walked by him and he started attacking me.” She claimed he punched her in the ribs while she was holding the baby, so she pulled a folding knife from her bra and stabbed him to get him off her.
“Like a Punch”
At trial, the husband described the moment to jurors.
“I feel blunt, dull pain, like a punch, in the right side of my neck,” he testified. He said he screamed at Richardson, asking what she had done. She shouted back, “You beat me!”
What the Camera Saw
The strongest evidence came from a bedroom security camera.
Investigators said the footage showed Richardson hitting herself several times with a small sledgehammer. This happened about two to three hours before the stabbing, before her husband even got home.
According to the affidavit, the hammer appeared to be swung “with just enough force that it would leave a mark on a person.” Investigators later found bruises on her that were round and matched the shape of the sledgehammer head.
The Knife That Wouldn’t Open
Detectives said the physical evidence did not match Richardson’s account:
- There was blood in the home but no sign of a struggle
- The knife had no spring-assisted mechanism, so it likely could not be opened with one hand
- Richardson tried to show investigators how she opened it one-handed and failed
- Investigators could not open and lock the blade with one hand either
Messages to Herself
Investigators also searched Richardson’s phone. They found she had sent herself messages about domestic abuse and saved material about how to testify about abuse.
Medical records showed no documented history of abuse by her husband, and his phone showed nothing that suggested he had been abusive. Investigators did find that Richardson had voiced worries about divorce and losing custody of her children.
The Fibromyalgia Claim
In follow-up interviews, Richardson said hitting herself with the sledgehammer was an alternative treatment for fibromyalgia, a chronic pain condition.
The jury did not believe her.
What Happens Next
Richardson had pleaded not guilty in May 2026. She was represented by attorney Dylan Rosalez, and Judge Kerri Johnson presided over the case. At that time she was free on a $30,000 cash or surety bond.
She now faces up to 10 years in prison and a $10,000 fine. A sentencing date had not been set as of Friday afternoon.
Need Help?
If you or someone you know is dealing with domestic violence, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is available 24/7 at 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788.

Robert J. Anaya is a writer and editor at WAMB Radio, covering local news and crime news for Wabash-area communities and Rockville. He is committed to reporting accurate, fact-checked, and timely stories that help local readers stay informed and safe.


