
Pittsburgh’s police chief says the city is close to finishing its review of two violent arrests in Downtown Pittsburgh last month that left both people seriously injured. A well-known civil rights attorney says the force used was not justified.
The Chief: “In the Next Few Weeks”
Pittsburgh Police Chief Jason Lando told WPXI Chief Investigator Rick Earle that the bureau is reviewing video and interviewing witnesses to evaluate the officers’ conduct. A use-of-force expert is also reviewing the arrest of Roy Cosby.
“All of those things take a while, especially scheduling the interviews with the witnesses, and we expect in the next few weeks to have some sort of outcome on those,” Lando said.
Arrest No. 1: Roy Cosby
The first arrest happened near Fifth Avenue and Wood Street, outside PNC Bank and near a police substation, just after 5:30 p.m. on a Monday.
What police say:
- According to a criminal complaint, Cosby, 31, intimidated a Pittsburgh Regional Transit bus driver, hit the bus windshield with his hand, and fought officers who tried to arrest him.
- The officer said he believed Cosby was reaching into his waistband for a weapon, so he punched Cosby several times in the face and stomach.
- No weapon was found.
What his family says:
- His sister, Camri Cosby, said he got upset after his bus passed his stop, so he ran to the next stop to catch it.
- She said he suffered broken ribs, a broken eye socket and bleeding in his brain.
- “My brother did not have to be treated like that over a bus,” she said.
A bystander recorded the end of the arrest on video. The officer involved has been placed on desk duty while the investigation continues.
Cosby is charged with resisting arrest and disorderly conduct. He’s scheduled for a preliminary hearing next month.
Arrest No. 2: Near the Convention Center
The second arrest involved a woman identified as Tamika Depts, near the David L. Lawrence Convention Center.
According to reports, Depts was being treated for a medical emergency when she allegedly threatened a paramedic and hit the paramedic in the hand. Officers handcuffed her. When she kicked an officer, the officer pushed her to the ground. She hit her head and lost consciousness.
Earlier this week, all criminal charges against Depts, including aggravated assault, were withdrawn.
Attorney: “That Is Concerning to Me”
Personal injury and civil rights attorney Todd Hollis represents Cosby. He previously settled an $8 million wrongful death lawsuit against the city over the death of Jim Rogers.
“Based upon my review, I don’t think any of the things that happened to Mr. Cosby was warranted,” Hollis said.
He also questioned accountability for the officers:
“Not to put a black mark on the good job that our city of Pittsburgh police are doing, and others in the country, but it concerns me that a person can be handcuffed and receive that level of force and you now know that measure not be tantamount to a police officer losing his job. That is concerning to me,” Hollis said.
Multiple Reviews Underway
Beyond the police bureau’s internal review:
- Mayor Corey O’Connor has brought in an outside expert for an independent review of the Cosby arrest
- The Independent Citizen Police Review Board is also investigating
So far, the officer in the Cosby case remains on administrative duty, and no other officers have faced discipline.
Cosby is presumed innocent of the charges against him unless proven guilty in court.

Robert J. Anaya is a writer and editor at WAMB Radio, covering local news and crime news for Wabash-area communities and Rockville. He is committed to reporting accurate, fact-checked, and timely stories that help local readers stay informed and safe.


