
Two sisters from Rochester, Indiana, are facing criminal charges after police say an argument between them turned physical inside their home while three children were there.
What Police Say Happened
The incident took place on Nov. 4, when a Rochester Police officer was called to a home about a physical fight. The woman who called said she and her sister had been fighting.
When the officer arrived, Alexandria Mae Holloway, 28, was standing outside. She told police that she and her sister, 23-year-old Dallas Kay Holloway, had been arguing when Dallas got in her face, pushed her and began swinging at her. The officer noticed scratches and red marks on Alexandria’s chest and arms, along with a knot on her head.
Alexandria also told officers that her sister was pregnant.
The Sister’s Side of the Story
Inside the home, Dallas Holloway gave the officer a different account. According to court documents, she said she believed Alexandria was about to hit her, so she pushed her and swung back. She also told police she blacked out after her sister hit her.
Dallas said the fight started because Alexandria had been saying things about her son. The officer saw red marks and scratches on Dallas’s face, neck and chest, which she said came from Alexandria choking her. Alexandria told police she was only trying to get her sister off of her.
Three children were inside the home during the fight.
Charges Filed
Both women were arrested.
Alexandria Holloway is charged with:
- Battery resulting in injury to a pregnant woman, a Level 5 felony
- Domestic battery in the presence of children, a Level 6 felony
- Disorderly conduct, a Class B misdemeanor
Dallas Holloway is charged with:
- Domestic battery in the presence of children, a Level 6 felony
- Disorderly conduct, a Class B misdemeanor
What These Charges Could Mean
Under Indiana law, a Level 5 felony carries a possible sentence of one to six years, with an advisory sentence of three years and a fine of up to $10,000. A Level 6 felony, the lowest felony level in the state, can bring six months to two and a half years. A Class B misdemeanor carries up to 180 days in jail and a fine of up to $1,000.
Indiana treats domestic violence with children present more seriously, which is why the domestic battery charges were filed as felonies.
Both women are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
Need Help?
If you or someone you know is dealing with domestic violence, help is available 24/7 through the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233, or by texting “START” to 88788. In an emergency, always call 911.

Robert J. Anaya is a writer and editor at WAMB Radio, covering local news and crime news for Wabash-area communities and Rockville. He is committed to reporting accurate, fact-checked, and timely stories that help local readers stay informed and safe.


